The Replacements: Josh Rosebrook Nutrient Day Cream

In making the switch to green beauty, some products are particularly hard to replace. In this series of posts I will  highlight the treasures discovered during my search for products that work as well, if not better, as their conventional counterparts.

In the annals of green beauty products that just never quite measure up to the conventional alternatives, two products prove especially impossible: mascara and sunscreen. Now, finding clean mascara that works well is a pain, but, truth be told, I am not hugely bothered about using dirty mascara (though I have finally found a clean favorite). After all, I hardly ever use it and, ultimately, the ingredients in many high-quality “dirty” mascaras are not all that terrible. Sunscreen, though is another story. We are expected to wear it daily, it covers most of our bodies or, at the very least, our entire faces and a lot of the dirty sunscreens have truly nasty ingredients, hormone disruptors being particularly dangerous culprits. Natural sunscreens use physical UVA and UVB blockers like zinc and titanium dioxide instead of chemicals and while both of those are perfectly effective, they are also notorious for leaving a white cast on the skin. I happen to absolutely adore my daily sunscreen, Suntegrity’s Face Sunscreen and Primer. It smells deliciously of citrus, provides a high level of sun protection and contains fantastic ingredients. But if anyone tries to tell you that it does not leave a white cast, they either have remarkably absorbent skin or they are not being entirely honest.

Sure, it does absorb eventually and even seems to smooth the look of my skin, but for a fair amount of time after application, I end up looking like a ghost – not entirely ideal when I need to run out the doors, while managing to look presentable. If my face gets oily, the sunscreen also tends to leave white streaks across my forehead. In addition, physical sunscreens make my face too hot, making my lips bead with perspiration any time the temperature gets anywhere near comfortably warm. Obviously, this is not exactly ideal for a New Yorker who spends quite a percentage of her life in hot subways or on steamy streets.

I have tried using sunscreens with clear zinc that promised sun protection without ghostification. Both the DeVita Solar Protective Moisturizer and Mychelle Replenishing Solar Defense came with great reviews and had impressive ingredient lists, but they just did not work for my skin. Minutes after the application, my face would start itching, and towards the end of the day I would be an irritated, red-faced mess.

I have all, but given up on finding a quality sunscreen that didn’t turn me white as a sheet, until an order from Integrity Botanicals came with a sample of the Josh Rosebrook Nutrient Day Cream. The little flyer included with the sample claimed that the cream, which contains non-nano zinc oxide and provides an SPF of 30, would not leave a white cast and will help improve my skin with a host of fantastic ingredients. I must confess it took me a while to try the sample: I knew how I react to clear zinc and I just didn’t want to bother with the attendant irritation. In fact, I’m not quite sure why I ended up trying it after all: I suppose the intrepid skincare explorer in me took over. After that first reluctant application I was, frankly, shocked. The cream (through I would really describe it as a lotion) applied like a dream and did not, in fact, leave even the slightest of white casts. It also felt perfect on the skin, in the way that is usually achieved by luxury conventional skincare by the addition of silicones: my face felt silky, smooth and soothed. The whole day passed and I developed no irritation or redness, nor did my face get too hot.

I made short work of the sample, immediately bought a full size bottle and I can now honestly say that I never want to be without it. This cream (lotion, darn it!) is a joy to use, it feels luxurious and it is improving my skin. I also absolutely adore its smell. It is quite strong, though not at all cloying. Somehow, I detect a hint of chocolate, though there is no cocoa butter in the ingredients, but a friend who complemented me on my perfume when all I was wearing was the Day Cream described the scent as fresh and herbal, with a strong note of sandalwood. Whatever the scent, components I adore it, though it is  strong enough that those sensitive to scents might want to try a sample before committing to a full size (especially since this cream is not exactly cheap).

If I have to find one thing to criticize is that this cream (lotion!!!) does not quite play well with others. That is, it layers beautifully over my oils, but tends to pill over anything that has more of a lotion, gel or serum-like texture. The pilling is not too bad and I wouldn’t ordinarily mind, but since this is a sunscreen, I want to avoid compromising its integrity as best I can. That said, you really don’t need anything besides an oil (or nothing at all if you have oily skin) when wearing this cream (oh, I give up!) because with its excellent ingredients it can provide all the nourishment your skin may need.

15 responses to The Replacements: Josh Rosebrook Nutrient Day Cream

  1. I just stumbled across your blog and I love it! Your reviews are funny to read and you seem to point out all the important stuff! I used the Kimberly Sayer Light Day Cream with SPF30 until I discovered that I still got some sun damage from it.. So I need a higher SPF and I am now trying the MD Solar Science BB Cream with SPF50.. allthough the ingredients could be better I hope my skin will love it.

    • TheHermesHippie – Author

      Oh that is so sweet! Thank you so much! 🙂 If you need a high SPF, you could try Suntegrity (their tinted cream doesn’t leave a white cast). Also, the Elta MD screen is not clean, but if you have an issue with a white cast that natural sunscreens can leave, it’s the cleanest bet amongst the chemical screens.

      • Is it possible to mix this lotion 😉 up with the Gressa Corrective Fondation? Or should I first put the lotion and then the Fondation?

      • Yes, I meant the JR Lotion. I have quite normal/oily skin, is the JR lotion mattifying or will my skin look like a disco star after using it?..

      • TheHermesHippie – Author

        It’s not specifically mattifying, but it definitely has more of a matte texture than a dewey one. I don’t think it should leave you looking like a disco ball. Certainly not in winter 🙂

  2. Emanuella

    I recently (as in five minutes ago) tried the Josh Rosebrook lotion (I totally agree with you that it’s not quite the consistency of a cream). But after turning bright red and splotchy within 30 seconds, I realized I had a bad reaction and sprinted to my computer to see the ingredient list and if anyone else had a similar experience. I’m glad it worked for you! Do you have any other sunscreen suggestions?

    • TheHermesHippie – Author

      Oh no! That’s terrible 😦 You clearly have a sensitivity to one of the ingredients. I really like the Suntegrity 5-in-1, but it’s tinted. If you don’t mind the tint, I’d give it a shot. I haven’t tried it myself, but I also hear great things about the Pratima sunscreen.

  3. Sounds interesting! I’ve had a hard time trying to find a sunscreen as well. Currently I’m testing out a DIY sunscreen made of red raspberry seed oil (SPF 30) mixed with jojoba. I was reading the JR ingredients list & he’s got cayenne in it. I know that’s often an irritant but not sure if its in a large enough quantity to matter for me.

  4. janis

    As soon as reading about the cream i literally fell in love with it! It does everything i want it do,the only problem is the Price tag. Please suggest me of the closest as possible cheaper alternative ?

    • TheHermesHippie – Author

      Ah! Yes, price tag is always an issue with the really great green beauty products. I’m actually doing a roundup of daily SPF creams – should be up within a week. Can’t promise there will be anything cheap, but might be a few more reasonably priced options 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s